STC #11 - Gas Canister - Vote Closed

[doylle]

UnsteadyTeddy

Textures

A Sober Irishman


Snipergen

Texture

Flakk

Texture

TheoLogic

Texture

Big Toe


skullv

Texture

Noxious


doylle


neti

Textures

zudchu

Textures

[TheoLogic]

I voted zudchu. It was equal between zudchu and Doylle, but I voted Doylle last time...

[zudchu]

My vote goes to doylle.
Nice detail work and overall quialty, especially considering the time limit.

[nistrum]

buggerit i missed the deadline
just finnished lol

[Coldfire]

Another tricky choice... everyone did a great job but Zudchu, Noxious, Doylle and Flakk really stand out imho. I'm voting for Zudchu... I think his submission has a good mix of weathering and originality, while still being subtle.

Awsome work from everyone though.

[IronTaxi]

agreed.Zudchu for the win...the originality does it for me... reminds me of the first indiana jones movie..hehe..

damn man...you sure you dont have time to texture some ships?

[Sentientv2]

I voted for Doylle. I liked all of Zudchu's except for the label. It looks very fake (I couldn't find a more polite word, no offense intended). There seems to be too much shadow around it. I'm not sure how much a normal map for the label would have helped, it just seems to lack some depth. The texture resolution on the label seems to be lower (or perhaps the edges aren't as sharp) compared to the eagle emblem below it as well. Aside from that label , I absolutely love it.

Great job everyone. I'll jump in the big boy pool eventually.

[Tiros]

Too bad I weren't able to join this comp, were on a LAN so missed it :/

Hmm, judging this one is kinda hard... there's two things here which can be found in every entry, which kinda makes me dislike all of them... but, I might just be a bit nitpicky

Those two things would be: Distribution of grunge/scratches, and the seams :/

Well, I narrowed it down to three entries.

UnsteadyTeddy: I liked the grunge in this one, though it's a bit too uniform for me, and the texture is also pretty blurry. That along with a very obvious seam lets it down a bit for me

Doylle: It's a nice entry, although, there's a few things I don't like here either. The shadow at edge of the labels are a bit too strong. The green colour is a bit too saturated and the metal doesn't realy look right.

Zudchu: The surface has a bit too contrasty grunge making it look a bit like it's amde out of stone. The label has jaggedy edges and look a bit deformed in a odd way. And the distribution of those scratches are a bit too odd, they're very instense around the seams.


Sorry is I sound a bit bitter, but I got a horrible case of sciatica atm which kinda pissed me off a bit... terribly annoying not being able to move as one would like without ones leg hurting like hell >_<

So, please don't take these crits in a bad way.. I prolly wouldn't have been able to do it much better myself..

Anyhow.. my vote will have to go with Doylle, His entry had the least obvious seam, combined with an artsy look.

Cheers!

[doylle]

congrats to zudchu