STC #10 - Garbage Cans - Vote Closed

[HollowIchigoBanki]

I felt addi's texture was very photo realistic but could have been laided out better with bigger shots of the bins, but doylle's was laided out very well but was not quite as photo realistic.

I was a hard choice i had to go with addi as it was so photo realistic

[Addi]

I still cant see doylle's first one, kinda annoying me now >.<
also, photobucket fails at resizing! I uploaded a bigger render.. here
I guess in future I'll use something else.

I voted for skullv, I dunno.. something about the scratches I liked

[Jinx]

Hi Every Body!
hmm nice set of bins here, Was tempted to join the comp but well Final Year project kind of sucks time and life out of ya.
so ehum
I voted for Addi and being his housemate had nothing to do what so ever with my judgement not even his yummy food , but my reason was well out of the bunch his look more like the ones we got round town.

I got to say Noxious had me with his clean shiny material also doylle's second entry (cant see the 1st one) the logo looked worn off and every thing with a nice set of material to the body but there was no evidence that the bin was worn off

Hopefully I try to enter the next one my self

[IronTaxi]

sober irishmans for me..it struck me pretty good when i saw it and made me take a second glance at the plastic texture... seems to be a nice wavey randomness of colour in the plastic without being too obvious

[A Sober Irishman]

Originally Posted by IronTaxi

sober irishmans for me..it struck me pretty good when i saw it and made me take a second glance at the plastic texture... seems to be a nice wavey randomness of colour in the plastic without being too obvious

Woooo! My first ever vote in a competition! Finally someone appreciates my artistic genius lol. Just kidding. Thanks for the vote man.

[Tiros]

Well, I told you to go for subtle grunge, didn't I?

Well, this one was so bloody hard.. but.. I guess I'll have to go for Doylle.. Some may think it's a bit unfair for him participating since he's so darn good, but he's still a member and does ofc have the right to.. besides, if it weren't for him, we wouldn't even have this comp, eh? I think he deserves a fair judging as any other member would

So, I'll have to go for Doylle's entry, pure art! (Could've added some more detail on the normal for those wheels though, and made the weld-seam show a bit more at the footer-thingies)

Cheers

[Sentientv2]

Originally Posted by Minotaur0

I'll go with doylle's second entry, although it doesnt make much sense it looks pretty cool.

I agree. Nice job on the texturing, but it was a hard sale on that type of trashcan being made of metal. Almost looked like a distressed plastic, but the metal patched texture drove it away from that feel.

Nice job all. I hope to give this all a try this week while I am off from school

[doylle]

Alright. Bit of a late end, sory for that.

anywayz, Congrats doylle