STC #06 - Shields - Vote Closed(Image heavy!)

doylle · 13-01-2008, 11:54 AM

Craig Lewis

Texture

e-freak

Talon

OpenDNS

ZeroCool

OpenDNS

Minotaur0

Texture

doylle

Texture

laughing_bun

Texture

I.C.

Texture

3rdman

Texture

nistrum

Texture

e-freek - Second Entry

Thanoz

Texture

Fleistad

Texture

Dark Soldier

Texture

Baida

Texture

showNOmercy

Texture

Thanoz - second entry

Texture

Sol1d

Texture

AHashem

Texture

hisshi

Texture

P2xelgen

Texture

KDun12

Texture

Fleistad - Second entry

Texture

Thorjan

Texture

meckanism

Texture

Corsair970

Texture

Grizzly3d

Texture

svelle

Texture

Corsair970 - second entry

Texture

Lord Ash

Texture

Corsair970 - Third entry

Texture

Karyuu

Texture

e-freak · 13-01-2008, 12:35 PM

Voted Fleistad Nr2 because of excellence but that was a really tough one. There have been so many, so sweet entries. And the range of artstyles was incredible. From realistic to fantasy, from comic to fotodetail. The two different Models make it even "worse" - heavy modern swat shields versus light wood shield isn't an easy decision.

Talon · 13-01-2008, 12:56 PM

Fleistad's first entry wins it for me. I really liked the normal map, although the spec is a little overpowered.

Sol1d's entry is a very close second, but I feel the extra normal work and stuff that Fliestad managed pushes his a little higher.

P2xelgen · 13-01-2008, 01:18 PM

This has been a great comp.
This was my first and not my last comp post. Its a great way to learn and hone your skills. So meny entries and all good in there own way, but its the last post that really made up my mind. So Karyuu gets my vote, I just love the style and look.

Thorjan · 13-01-2008, 01:22 PM

Voted for Sol1d , really liked the texture
Fleistad second entry also looked very good.
Alot of entries this time

Craig Lewis · 13-01-2008, 01:31 PM

I'd liked to have voted for myself, but that'd be cheating. I think Fleistads second entry is my favourite, though a lot of other are also great.

I'll definitely be taking part in more challenges in the future, as I enjoyed doing this.

Doylle, was the riot shield model yours? Would you have any obligations to me finishing off my texture to put on my portfolio (with full credit to yourself of course)?

Kinrove · 13-01-2008, 02:00 PM

Fleistad's first for me... I like that Kevlar Shield and the texture are very great.
Otherwise that was very cool to take part in this competition, many entries and many things to learn in same time

mmcleo11 · 13-01-2008, 02:25 PM

Wow thats a tough 1. Loads of very good work

Had to vote Sol1d tho the normals gave it that sickeningly amazing look lol

|Buddy| · 13-01-2008, 05:08 PM

Fleistad is dominating!

I would vote both of his entries if I could.

Kaskad · 13-01-2008, 05:33 PM

It was tough to choose between Fleistad and Karyuu, but ultimately I was more impressed with Karyuu's entry for both its creativity and detail.

View Poll Results: Who made the best shield texture?
Craig Lewis	8	9.09%
e-freak	2	2.27%
Talon	0	0%
ZeroCool	1	1.14%
Minotaur0	5	5.68%
doylle	4	4.55%
laughin_bun	0	0%
I.C.	0	0%
3rdman	0	0%
nistrum	0	0%
e-freak - second entry	0	0%
Thanoz	0	0%
Fleistad	7	7.95%
Dark Soldier	0	0%
Baida	0	0%
showNOmercy	0	0%
Thanoz - second entry	1	1.14%
Sol1d	4	4.55%
AHashem	0	0%
hisshi	0	0%
P2xelgen	0	0%
KDun12	1	1.14%
Fleistad - second entry	16	18.18%
Thorjan	0	0%
meckanism	3	3.41%
Corsair970	0	0%
Grizzly3D	0	0%
svelle	0	0%
Corsair970 - second entry	1	1.14%
Lord Ash	1	1.14%
Corsair970 - Third entry	3	3.41%
Karyuu	31	35.23%
Voters: 88. You may not vote on this poll

13-01-2008, 11:54 AM	#1 (permalink)
doylle Industry Artist 3,375 - 4,400	STC #06 - Shields - Vote Closed(Image heavy!) Craig Lewis Texture e-freak Talon OpenDNS ZeroCool OpenDNS Minotaur0 Texture doylle Texture laughing_bun Texture I.C. Texture 3rdman Texture nistrum Texture e-freek - Second Entry Thanoz Texture Fleistad Texture Dark Soldier Texture Baida Texture showNOmercy Texture Thanoz - second entry Texture Sol1d Texture AHashem Texture hisshi Texture P2xelgen Texture KDun12 Texture Fleistad - Second entry Texture Thorjan Texture meckanism Texture Corsair970 Texture Grizzly3d Texture svelle Texture Corsair970 - second entry Texture Lord Ash Texture Corsair970 - Third entry Texture Karyuu Texture __________________ Environment artist - EA dice JeroenMaton.net Sketchbook Last edited by doylle; 13-01-2008 at 12:01 PM.

13-01-2008, 12:56 PM	#3 (permalink)
Talon Industry Artist 3,798 - 1,396	Fleistad's first entry wins it for me. I really liked the normal map, although the spec is a little overpowered. Sol1d's entry is a very close second, but I feel the extra normal work and stuff that Fliestad managed pushes his a little higher. __________________ > My Portfolio > Supporter of good crits.

13-01-2008, 01:18 PM	#4 (permalink)
P2xelgen Senior Member 271 - 22	This has been a great comp. This was my first and not my last comp post. Its a great way to learn and hone your skills. So meny entries and all good in there own way, but its the last post that really made up my mind. So Karyuu gets my vote, I just love the style and look. __________________ Myblog Find my works here.

13-01-2008, 01:31 PM	#6 (permalink)
Craig Lewis Industry Artist 955 - 206	I'd liked to have voted for myself, but that'd be cheating. I think Fleistads second entry is my favourite, though a lot of other are also great. I'll definitely be taking part in more challenges in the future, as I enjoyed doing this. Doylle, was the riot shield model yours? Would you have any obligations to me finishing off my texture to put on my portfolio (with full credit to yourself of course)? __________________

13-01-2008, 12:35 PM	#2 (permalink)
e-freak Game Art Student 44 - 4	Voted Fleistad Nr2 because of excellence but that was a really tough one. There have been so many, so sweet entries. And the range of artstyles was incredible. From realistic to fantasy, from comic to fotodetail. The two different Models make it even "worse" - heavy modern swat shields versus light wood shield isn't an easy decision.

13-01-2008, 01:22 PM	#5 (permalink)
Thorjan Frequenter 114 - 18	Voted for Sol1d , really liked the texture Fleistad second entry also looked very good. Alot of entries this time

13-01-2008, 02:00 PM	#7 (permalink)
Kinrove Senior Member 590 - 15	Fleistad's first for me... I like that Kevlar Shield and the texture are very great. Otherwise that was very cool to take part in this competition, many entries and many things to learn in same time __________________ My Portfolio My Blog

13-01-2008, 02:25 PM	#8 (permalink)
mmcleo11 Senior Member 230 - 69	Wow thats a tough 1. Loads of very good work Had to vote Sol1d tho the normals gave it that sickeningly amazing look lol

13-01-2008, 05:08 PM	#9 (permalink)
\|Buddy\| Frequenter 132 - 24	Fleistad is dominating! I would vote both of his entries if I could. __________________ She says the jungle... it just came alive and took him. www.buddypowered.com

13-01-2008, 05:33 PM	#10 (permalink)
Kaskad Banned 632 - 82	It was tough to choose between Fleistad and Karyuu, but ultimately I was more impressed with Karyuu's entry for both its creativity and detail.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode