Speed Modeling Competition 2: 007: Modular Fence - Voting Thread

[Polygoblin]

Here are our nominees!

VOTE FOR YOUR FAVORITE NOW!

The poll will be open for one week
Click the images to see each persons submission post.





rockstar6






Zanrok








borgking









Piflik







naked_chicken









penE






talldrinks







EyecyArt












megalmn2000

Voting For Your Own Submissions Is Allowed

[Oniram]

borgking got my vote. looks really great and seems like it would be fairly simple but fun to texture.

[Arsenal]

"Voting For Your Own Submissions Is Allowed"

is this a joke?

[Polygoblin]

Originally Posted by Arsenal

"Voting For Your Own Submissions Is Allowed"

is this a joke?

Lol, no it is not a joke. We have discussed the policy here and decided it may serve everyone's best interests if you had the option to vote for yourself from now on. We still have ways of telling if someone creates multiple accounts to vote. Many other comps also allow it.

Artists are suggested to make honest decisions about their vote, and to select their favorite, even if it's their own. After all, it's important to like your own work too

[borgking]

Ok, i will compile my thoughs on all the models:
1. rockstar6:
Well, i allready criticised this model when it still was wip. Also i recommend checking your smothing groups.
2. Zanrok:
Looks too simple, you could spend much more polys.
3. myself:
i simply cannot criticise myself, next one
4. Piflik:
Looks good mesh-wise, though ao/bump look way to noisy
5. naked_chicken:
difficult one, since obviously textures are missing. Also a real third part is missing...
6. penE:
clearly my favourite, great mesh, good normals.
7. talldrinks:
Do not mix up highpoly and crazybump! Also the barbed wire looks kind of chaotic, messy.
8. EyecyArt:
the pillar looks kind of strange. Also ao is not comming out due to the strange squares.
9. megalmn2000:
Looks great, but misses the topic.
Also breaking up the horizontal shapes with something vertical or even diagonal would be a massive upgrade the shape composition of the model.

[mdale13]

Originally Posted by Polygoblin

Lol, no it is not a joke. We have discussed the policy here and decided it may serve everyone's best interests if you had the option to vote for yourself from now on. We still have ways of telling if someone creates multiple accounts to vote. Many other comps also allow it.

Artists are suggested to make honest decisions about their vote, and to select their favorite, even if it's their own. After all, it's important to like your own work too

I would have won that texturing competition! booooooo Nah, I actually liked the tie! good fun.




I voted for the wall I would most want to texture! Its always got to be megalmn2000. Well done.

[Polygoblin]

Originally Posted by mdale13

I would have won that texturing competition! booooooo Nah, I actually liked the tie! good fun.

Yeah, it's a new policy

But again, I stress that artists are encouraged to make honest decisions about voting. Honoring the quality of another artist's work is never a bad thing.

[EyecyArt]

Voted for megalmn, too. Nice UV Layout and good bakes.

@ borking
Agree with your comments, can´t remark anything.
To your entry, just a solid model and bakes. Only thing would be some details. The Fences in my garden have angled metal plates holding the Pillar and the frame togehter and some caps on it tops.

I reached my goal, one Vote! And its not my own

[joukejan]

I voted for Rockstar6. I judged all pieces on different points. For these competitions I always look for originality, style and time. rockstar6 already jumped out for me on originality and style. I know it won't take long to make it but I dig the style.

@ megalmn2000: I really like your model but I actually didn't see a fence in your model. To me there wall pieces. But great work.

[rednaz]

I really like Piflik's entry, the bricks came out really nice from the hp!