Forums   Articles   Events
SEARCH:
LOGIN:
Register Register Register Contact Us
Go Back   Game Artist Forums > Challenges > Competition Archive > GAMC #2 - Leather Chair
Register FAQForum Rules Members List Calendar Mark Forums Read
View Poll Results: Who submitted the best entry?
snake85027 0 0%
ez_jamin 5 4.27%
Mist 16 13.68%
midduke 0 0%
TheCorey 1 0.85%
Kaleb3d 31 26.50%
[hp] 15 12.82%
lordgobbo 0 0%
poostayn 10 8.55%
Kasatik 0 0%
MeintevdS 0 0%
Bordy 0 0%
StheV 1 0.85%
pAldred 0 0%
neenerpants 1 0.85%
Tiros 18 15.38%
Ibrahim 18 15.38%
twiesner 0 0%
Chaosquack 0 0%
manlouk 1 0.85%
Duality 0 0%
westmeadow 0 0%
SectorClear 0 0%
Voters: 117. You may not vote on this poll

 
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 07-09-2009, 07:48 AM   #1 (permalink)
Freelancer
Tiros's Avatar
1st Place Winner of Speed Texturing 1st Place Winner of Speed Texturing Winner of Speed Modeling Winner of Speed Texturing Silver Star 
Tiros's User Activity: 10/10
2,472 - 819
GAMC #2 - Voting Thread

During the voting period, everyone has the right to vote. You may not vote for yourself. Doing so will disqualify you from the competition, and you will not be eligable for the prize regardless of the amount of votes you recieved.

The voting process will run for 1 week. If you fail to vote during that week, you loose your right to vote in this competition. The winner will be the person with the highest score. If multiple entries tie for first place, members of the staff will vote for a winner.

Best regards,

Mini-Competition Staff
Proudly supported by CGSociety
Sponsored by CGTextures.com



snake85027



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 1032

David Bailey


ez_jamin



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 1178

Ben Dalling - ez_jamin@hotmail.co.uk


Mist



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 1348

Nicholas Etheridge - nicholasetheridge@hotmail.com


midduke



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 1952

Luke Middleton - luke.middleton@live.com


TheCorey




Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 1152

Sander de Laat - Sanderdlart@gmail.com


Kaleb3d



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 1961

Kaleb Aylsworth - kaleb_aylsworth@hotmail.com


[hp]



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 1798

Hélder Pinto - helderhp "@" gmail . com


lordgobbo



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 1976

Jeremy Grenier - lordgobbo@sympatico.ca


poostayn



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 1,920

JeffLoftin - Jefroodc@yahoo.com


Kasatik



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 1988

Alexandr Kasatikov - alexandr.kasatikov@gmail.com


MeintevdS



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 1870

Meinte van der Spiegel - ruined.3d@gmail.com


Bordy



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 1726

Bordás Gábor - gabor.bordas@gmail.com


StheV



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 1527

Steven de Vries - stevo.de.vries@gmail.com


pAldred



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 920

Peter Aldred - pAldred@compnext.com


neenerpants



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 328

Dom Ireland - domireland@gmail.com


Tiros



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 1275

Adam Fransson - empusary[at]hotmail.com


Ibrahim



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 1,948

Ibrahim Wahab - wahab_ibrahim@hotmail.com


twiesner



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 1,808

Tanya Wiesner - tanya.wiesner@gmail.com


Chaosquack



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 1762

Nick Quackenbush - nickquackenbush@gmail.com


manlouk



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 1684

Man Louk Chin - manlouk@yahoo.com


Duality



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 1880

Gonzalo Martinez - gamartto [ at ] live [.] com.


westmeadow



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 1368

Arron Westley - assieuk@googlemail.com


SectorClear



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 674

Jordan Stolearcius - jordy@jord-art.com


Butz



Wireframe
Texturesheets
Triangle Count: 1910

Doru Butz - but.doru@gmail.com

Last edited by Tiros; 07-09-2009 at 12:49 PM.
Tiros is offline  
Old 07-09-2009, 08:02 AM   #2 (permalink)
New Member
d3cl4n's Avatar
d3cl4n's User Activity: 0/10
60 - 24
Mist's just has the little bit of something unique, got my vote.
d3cl4n is offline  
Old 07-09-2009, 08:06 AM   #3 (permalink)
Industry Artist
Dennispls's Avatar
Silver Star 
Dennispls's User Activity: 10/10
1,506 - 631
Kaleb got my vote.
Excellent execution of this chair. Lovely wear and tear and a very interesting choice of color.
The normals stand out really well and make this chair pop out above the other entries.

Very hard choice though cause there are more very well made chairs here.

Poostayn and Tiros would be the runner ups.
__________________
Good Crit!
Dennis Griesheimer
Lelystad, The Netherlands
Linkedin
Dennispls is offline  
Old 07-09-2009, 08:36 AM   #4 (permalink)
Frequenter
Kaleb3d's Avatar
Kaleb3d's User Activity: 0/10
118 - 15
I gave Tiros my vote.
The refined quality of his diffuse and specular textures created a very realistic material definition imo...that, and I liked the funky wheely things on the front legs too

Edit: I just wanted to note that Ibrahim was an extremely close second for me, with HP and Poostayn following right behind.
__________________
Kaleb3d

http://www.kaleb-3d.com

Last edited by Kaleb3d; 08-09-2009 at 10:53 AM. Reason: Additional props!
Kaleb3d is offline  
Old 07-09-2009, 09:41 AM   #5 (permalink)
New Member
twiesner's Avatar
twiesner's User Activity: 0/10
66 - 9
Hard Choice. Went with Ibrahim in the end.
__________________
Portfolio
LinkedIn
twiesner is offline  
Old 07-09-2009, 11:00 AM   #6 (permalink)
Frequenter
Chaosquack's User Activity: 0/10
82 - 6
I prefer [hp]'s but that detail map makes it look crazy good. Because of that Im gonna have to go with Kalebs.


Ibrahim, Tiros, Poostayn, Mist and a few others made the choice tough though!
Chaosquack is offline  
Old 07-09-2009, 12:46 PM   #7 (permalink)
Game Art Student
varoondextor's Avatar
varoondextor's User Activity: 0/10
105 - 10
HAHH hah was there anything like i needed to post my final thing in some other particular thread?
well didn't do any such last thing"
ok" let me take care next time"
__________________
varoondextor is offline  
Old 07-09-2009, 02:02 PM   #8 (permalink)
New Member
MeintevdS's User Activity: 0/10
43 - 4
I wasn't sure wether to pick Tiros or Kaleb, but went with Tiros in the end. Tiros really captured the leather feeling of the chair in my oppinion and didn't go to overboard with the damage, which fits his chair.

The reason I didn't go with Kaleb is because his chair had a looks a bit like stone to me. His normal map also causes his texture to lose some of it's details, and gave the chair (not sure if this is the right word to use, but I can't think of a better one) a 'muddy' feeling. Especially the edges of the patches look a bit blurry/muddy to me.

Good job to all who finished this mini competition, alot of them look really nice.
MeintevdS is offline  
Old 07-09-2009, 06:31 PM   #9 (permalink)
Senior Member
pAldred's Avatar
pAldred's User Activity: 0/10
369 - 33
Voted for Ibrahim!
__________________
Projects I'm working on: Tactical-Assault

Portfolio - www.compnext.com

LinkedIn - http://www.linkedin.com/in/pAldred
pAldred is offline  
Old 07-09-2009, 06:39 PM   #10 (permalink)
Senior Member
Ibrahim's Avatar
Ibrahim's User Activity: 10/10
330 - 642
Tiros, Kaleb, HP and Poostayn have produced excellent entries here, but my vote is going to Tirso. It's the texturing that impressed me the most about it his piece.

And thanks to all who voted for me
__________________
- Portfolio
- Scrapbook
- LinkedIn
Ibrahim is offline  
 

Bookmarks
Digg del.icio.us StumbleUpon Google
Thread Tools
Display Modes




All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:47 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.0 Beta 4
Copyright ©2000 - 2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.1.0
Copyright © 2006-2008 Game-Artist.Net